Breakeven Math
You only need to win
1 in 20 cases to cover the cost Brundage Group support.
Our data shows at least $5,000 is earned for every P2P overturned. Brundage Group only needs to overturn 5.3% for positive ROI.
Run Your Own Numbers
Every input below is live. Enter your info to unlock it.
If you don’t know your in-house pursuit rate or overturn rate yet, leave the defaults — they’re a reasonable illustrative starting point. Tell us who you are and the calculator unlocks instantly.
Every input below is live.
If you don’t know your in-house pursuit rate or overturn rate yet, leave the defaults – they’re a reasonable illustrative starting point.
Unlocked for John Smith
Monthly P2P Opportunities
In-House Team
Pursuit Rate
Overturn Rate
Brundage Group Program
Pursuit Rate
Overturn Rate
Revenue per Overturn ($)
5000.00
Figures above are illustrative estimates based on the inputs you provide. They are not a guarantee of results, revenue, overturn rate, or pursuit rate — actual outcomes depend on your payer mix, documentation, and case specifics, and will vary. Cost-per-case assumptions are held constant behind the scenes and reflected in the figures above.
Where P2P programs actually lose money
Most missed P2Ps aren’t a clinical loss. They’re an operational one.
Industry-wide, hospital denial rates hit 11.6% in 2025, and net revenue leakage from denials grew 25% year over year — to roughly $48.4B across U.S. hospitals. That trend isn’t driven by weaker clinical arguments. It’s driven by a process that can’t keep up with the payer’s clock.
P2P scheduling windows can be as short as 24–72 hours from the denial notice. When a hospitalist or Physician Advisor is handling that on top of a full clinical load, the call gets missed for reasons that have nothing to do with whether the case was defensible — the denial notice sat in an inbox, the window closed overnight, the chart wasn’t pulled together in time.
Signs your current P2P workflow is leaking revenue:
- Calls are handled by whichever Physician Advisor or hospitalist has a free hour, not a dedicated team.
- No one tracks your actual pursuit rate — the % of eligible P2Ps that get a call at all.
- Missed calls default straight to the post-discharge appeal, weeks of delayed payment later.
- You know your overturn rate, but not what you’re losing on the calls that never happened.
If two or more of those sound familiar, the gap isn’t hypothetical; it’s happening every month, quietly, as cases that were never called instead of cases that were called and lost. The calculator above puts a number on it. See what it’s costing you.
Per-case economics
The cleanest way to frame this doesn’t depend on guessing your volume.
Every case that gets a P2P call has the same underlying math, regardless of how many you do in a month.
| Per 100 Opportunities | Assume $265 Cost / $5000 Revenue per Overturn |
|---|---|
| Cost per case taken | $265.00 |
| Overturn rate | 65% |
| Revenue per overturn | $5,000.00 |
| Expected net revenue per case taken | $2,985 |
| ROI multiple | 11.3x (1,126% ROI) |
For every $1 spent on P2P review at these rates, roughly $11.26 comes back — purely from the cases actually taken.
The capture gap
The real story isn’t cost per case. It’s volume captured.
A fixed-cost in-house Physician Advisor doesn’t get cheaper by taking fewer calls — so every P2P they don’t get to isn’t a savings, it’s lost revenue at zero marginal cost avoided. Per 100 opportunities, at a 50% in-house pursuit rate vs. a 95% pursuit rate:
| Per 100 Opportunities | In-house (50%) | Our Program (95%) |
|---|---|---|
| Cases taken | 50 | 95 |
| Overturns @ 65% | 32.5 | 61.75 |
| Revenue captured | $162,500 | $308,750 |
The gap — roughly $146,000 per 100 opportunities — is money left on the table because in-house can’t answer the phone consistently, not because of overturn skill.
P2P Denial Program Economics
The real cost of P2P isn’t the fee. It’s the calls no one answers.
Most P2P programs don’t lose revenue because the clinical argument was weak. They lose it because the call never happened. Here’s how to tell if that’s costing you — and exactly how much.
Full Report
Your Modeled Results
Here’s what the capture gap looks like with your numbers.
Based on what you plugged in, here’s the monthly gap between an in-house team and a program that answers nearly every call.
Monthly
Capture Gap:
$122,975
$1.4M/year
These figures are illustrative estimates based on the inputs submitted and are not a guarantee of revenue, overturn rate, pursuit rate, or any other outcome. Actual results depend on payer mix, case documentation, and other organization-specific factors, and will vary.
Net Revenue With Brundage Group:
$285,475
$3.4M/year
These figures are illustrative estimates based on the inputs submitted and are not a guarantee of revenue, overturn rate, pursuit rate, or any other outcome. Actual results depend on payer mix, case documentation, and other organization-specific factors, and will vary.
In-house
Net Revenue:
$162,500
$1.9M/year
These figures are illustrative estimates based on the inputs submitted and are not a guarantee of revenue, overturn rate, pursuit rate, or any other outcome. Actual results depend on payer mix, case documentation, and other organization-specific factors, and will vary.
ROI on
Program Spend:
12.3x
These figures are illustrative estimates based on the inputs submitted and are not a guarantee of revenue, overturn rate, pursuit rate, or any other outcome. Actual results depend on payer mix, case documentation, and other organization-specific factors, and will vary.
| Per 100 Opportunities | In-house (50%) | Our Program (95%) |
|---|---|---|
| Pursuit rate | 50% | 95% |
| Cases taken | 50 | 95 |
| Overturn rate | 65% | 65% |
| Overturns won | 32.5 | 61.75 |
| Revenue captured (@ $5,000/overturn) | $162,500 | $308,750 |
Why Organizations Move this to Us
The gap above isn’t a skill problem. It’s a strategy problem.
Three things consistently separate a program that captures the numbers above from one that doesn’t.
Brundage Group runs your
P2P program at the pursuit rate your current numbers say you’re missing.
Your results above show a real, monthly gap — not a hypothetical. That gap exists because of capacity, not competence.
- Every eligible P2P opportunity gets a call, on the payer’s clock — not when staff has a free hour.
- You pay per case taken, so the economics scale with volume instead of a fixed salary risk.
- Overturn performance is tracked and reported against the same numbers shown above, month over month.
Ready to see this run against your live claims data, not a model?



